SiYuan alternatives

[TomLucidor]

This is going to be the first thing I would suggest, since I am starting to see that there are "universal tooling" for multiple IDEs https://github.com/intellectronica/ruler
But with Obsiidan and SiYuan, they have side panels for people to put plugins (similar to VSCode as the universal GUI), so there are ways around this. If there are ways to make the core the same, while standardizing actions between notetakers, it would be pretty useful for people to migrate. https://github.com/Asianfleet/siyuan-plugin-aether/issues https://github.com/jaar23/nb-assistant

[Lapis0x0]

That's a great idea. Considering that the vast majority of custom assistants still only customize the system prompt, providing a standardized import and export interface shouldn't be difficult.

[TomLucidor]

A good place to start is MCP-to-MCP compare (I am not sure which MCP would this level of feature coverage for Obsidian)
SiYuan side https://github.com/onigeya/siyuan-mcp-server https://github.com/xgq18237/siyuan_mcp_server
Best guesses https://github.com/aaronsb/obsidian-mcp-plugin https://github.com/infiolab/infio-copilot

Some SiYuan MCP with less options and closer to most Obsidian MCPs https://github.com/OpaqueGlass/syplugin-anMCPServer
Similar situation with Obsidian https://github.com/basicmachines-co/basic-memory https://github.com/StevenStavrakis/obsidian-mcp https://github.com/newtype-01/obsidian-mcp

[Lapis0x0]

I've already released the first version, and the plugin is currently awaiting review in the Obsidian store. Thank you so much for your suggestions. In the future, I'll explore more general and unified import/export formats and MCP migration😘

[TomLucidor]

Got LLMs to write down notes on how to move the features from Obsidian to SiYuan, feeling kinda dumb but it is doable, I wonder what it takes to bridge the UX tho
paragraph_block_operations.md page_document_operations.md search_operations.md workspace_vault_operations.md metadata_organization_operations.md