XMCL displays Modrinth "[Let's Do] WilderNature" file under "[Let's Do] Beachparty" as extra version

[LauriLepik]

Is there an existing issue for this?

• I have searched the existing issues

Launcher Version

v0.54.3

Operating System

Windows

Architecture

x64

Current Behavior

When installing [Let’s Do] WilderNature via the Modrinth integration, it does not appear as a separate installed entry; instead, the WilderNature jar (letsdo-wildernature-neoforge-1.1.4.jar) shows up inside the [Let’s Do] Beachparty mod page/version dropdown as an additional file/version.

Expected Behavior

Installing [Let’s Do] WilderNature should add it as its own mod entry (or at minimum keep its version list attached to the WilderNature project), not as a “version” of Beachparty.

Steps To Reproduce

1. Create/open an instance on Minecraft 1.21.1 with NeoForge.
2. Open "Install" Mods browser, search for "[Let’s Do] Beachparty" and click install.
3. Search for "[Let’s Do] WilderNature" and click Install.
4. Return to the Beachparty details page and open the “Selected Version” dropdown.
5. Observe that letsdo-wildernature-neoforge-1.1.4.jar appears listed there alongside Beachparty versions.

Anything else?

The WilderNature jar is present in the instance mods/ folder, so this appears to be a UI/association bug rather than a failed download. Im wondering what is causing this and if it could be also affecting other mods as well.

[ci010]

it does not repro for me. I wonder if it's some strange cache issue.

[ci010]

I repro it. I believe this is a bug of curseforge. This is the raw result query from curseforge

It tells me the project id is 858691, which is the Beachparty's project id.

The real id should be 1071657

[LauriLepik]

Hmm, that's interesting, but I installed both of them from Modrinth. So the system uses the CurseForge id in the background regardless of if the platform when both platforms are available?

[ci010]

Hmm, that's interesting, but I installed both of them from Modrinth. So the system uses the CurseForge id in the background regardless of if the platform when both platforms are available?

for any local mods file, the launcher will try the best effort to resolve it's modrinth/curseforge metadata if they are missing. So user can switch in the page. This is also useful for those who want to export modpack to both modrinth/curseforge.