[Pelis Agent Factory Advisor] Agentic Workflow Maturity Assessment and Recommendations

[github-actions[bot]]

📊 Executive Summary

After analyzing gh-aw-firewall against Pelis Agent Factory best practices, this repository demonstrates strong agentic workflow maturity (Level 4/5) with 15 active workflows covering security, quality, documentation, and CI/CD. The repository excels at security automation and CI failure investigation but has opportunities to add code quality workflows, metrics collection, and documentation validation - all proven patterns from the Pelis Agent Factory collection of 100+ workflows.

Key Strengths: Comprehensive security guard, automated CI diagnosis, test coverage improvement, dependency monitoring
Top Opportunities: Code simplification, metrics collector, documentation site testing, glossary maintenance
Quick Wins: 3 workflows could be added immediately with minimal effort and high impact

---

🎓 Patterns Learned from Pelis Agent Factory

Core Design Principles

1. Heterogeneous Specialization - 100+ specialized workflows vs. monolithic agents
2. Continuous AI - Daily/weekly/hourly schedules for continuous improvement
3. Meta-Agents - Agents monitoring agents (Metrics Collector, Portfolio Analyst, Audit Workflows)
4. Safety-First Architecture - Strict permissions + safe-outputs enable safe experimentation
5. Observable Everything - Natural language specs, auditable actions, remixable patterns

Workflow Categories (19 articles in "Meet the Workflows" series)

Category	Examples	Applicability to gh-aw-firewall
Code Quality	Continuous Simplicity, Duplicate Detector, Refactoring	✅ High - TypeScript codebase would benefit
Documentation	Daily Updater, Glossary Maintainer, Noob Tester, Multi-device Tester	✅ High - Has docs-site with Astro
Security	Security Guard, Secrets Analysis, Malicious Code Scan, Static Analysis	✅ Already strong - Has 5/5 workflows
Issue/PR Management	Triage, Issue Monster, Duplicate Detector	✅ Already implemented
Quality & Hygiene	CI Doctor, Schema Drift, Fault Investigation	✅ Already strong
Metrics & Analytics	Metrics Collector, Portfolio Analyst, Audit Workflows	❌ Missing - No agent ecosystem monitoring
Operations	Release automation, Build coordination	✅ Partial - Has release workflows
Multi-Phase	Long-running campaigns with coordination	❌ Missing - No complex workflows

Key Configuration Patterns from Pelis Factory

---
# Skip-if-match prevents duplicate PRs/issues
skip-if-match:
  query: 'is:pr is:open in:title "[Prefix]"'
  max: 1

# Network restriction by domain
network:
  allowed:
    - github

# Bash whitelisting (no wildcards)
tools:
  bash:
    - "npm ci"
    - "npm run:*"

# Safe outputs with limits
safe-outputs:
  create-pull-request:
    draft: true
    title-prefix: "[Type] "
    labels: [ai-generated]
  add-comment:
    max: 1

# Imports for shared patterns
imports:
  - shared/mcp-pagination.md

Comparison: gh-aw-firewall workflows follow these patterns well, with good use of skip-if-match, title prefixes, and network restrictions. Could benefit from more imports for shared logic.

---

📋 Current Agentic Workflow Inventory

Workflow	Purpose	Trigger	Assessment
security-guard.md	PR security review	pull_request	✅ Excellent - follows Pelis patterns
test-coverage-improver.md	Weekly test improvements	weekly schedule	✅ Good - security-focused testing
ci-doctor.md	CI failure investigation	workflow_run failure	✅ Excellent - Docker/network aware
doc-maintainer.md	Daily doc sync	daily schedule	✅ Good - tracks last 7 days of changes
issue-monster.md	Copilot agent assignment	hourly + on open	✅ Good - throttles with skip-if-match
issue-duplication-detector.md	Find duplicate issues	TBD	⚠️ Needs trigger configuration
dependency-security-monitor.md	Security vulnerabilities	TBD	⚠️ Good concept, check if active
security-review.md	Daily threat modeling	daily schedule	✅ Security-specific
ci-cd-gaps-assessment.md	Pipeline analysis	TBD	⚠️ Needs trigger
pelis-agent-factory-advisor.md	Meta-advisor (this!)	manual	✅ Self-aware meta-agent
plan.md	Planning workflow	manual	✅ Useful for coordinated work
smoke-claude.md	Claude integration test	TBD	✅ Validation workflow
smoke-copilot.md	Copilot integration test	TBD	✅ Validation workflow
release.md	Release automation	TBD	✅ Operations workflow
update-release-notes.md	Release notes maintenance	TBD	✅ Documentation workflow

Total: 15 agentic workflows
Active (with triggers): ~10
Needing activation: ~5

---

🚀 Actionable Recommendations

P0 - Implement Immediately (High Impact, Low Effort)

1. Code Simplification Workflow

What: Daily analysis of recent commits to find overcomplicated code and create PRs with simplifications

Why:

• TypeScript codebase (src/, tests/) has grown organically
• Security-critical code needs clarity (iptables, Squid config, Docker management)
• Pelis Factory reports this catches complexity after rapid development sessions

How: Adapt Pelis Factory's Automatic Code Simplifier

---
description: Analyzes recently modified code and creates PRs with simplifications
on:
  schedule: daily
  workflow_dispatch:
  skip-if-match:
    query: 'is:pr is:open in:title "[Simplify]"'
    max: 1
permissions:
  contents: read
tools:
  github:
    toolsets: [default]
  bash:
    - "npm ci"
    - "npm run build"
safe-outputs:
  create-pull-request:
    draft: true
    title-prefix: "[Simplify] "
    labels: [refactoring, ai-generated]
timeout-minutes: 15
---

# Code Simplifier

Analyze code changed in the last 7 days. Look for:
- Nested conditionals that could use early returns
- Repeated logic that should be extracted
- Verbose error handling that could be simplified
- Complex boolean expressions
- Functions doing too many things

Focus on security-critical files:
- src/host-iptables.ts
- src/squid-config.ts
- src/docker-manager.ts
- src/domain-patterns.ts

Create ONE focused PR with simplifications that preserve functionality.

Effort: Low (2-3 hours to adapt from Pelis Factory)
Example: Could have simplified complex iptables rule generation in host-iptables.ts

---

2. Documentation Site Validator

What: Daily validation that docs-site examples are accurate and links work

Why:

• Has Astro-based docs-site with CLI examples
• CLI flags change frequently
• Broken examples hurt adoption of a security tool
• Pelis Factory has "Documentation Noob Tester" and "Blog Auditor" patterns

How: Create workflow to verify docs-site content

---
description: Validates documentation site examples and links
on:
  schedule: daily
  workflow_dispatch:
permissions:
  contents: read
tools:
  github:
    toolsets: [default]
  bash:
    - "npm ci"
    - "grep:*"
    - "find:*"
safe-outputs:
  create-issue:
    title-prefix: "[Docs] "
    labels: [documentation, bug]
timeout-minutes: 10
---

# Documentation Site Validator

1. Find all code examples in docs-site/src/content/docs/
2. Extract CLI commands (lines starting with `awf` or `sudo awf`)
3. Check that flags match current CLI (compare with --help output)
4. Verify environment variable names exist in codebase
5. Check internal links point to existing files
6. Flag any outdated examples

Create ONE issue listing all problems found with specific file:line references.

Effort: Low (1-2 hours)
Impact: High - accurate docs critical for security tool adoption

---

3. Glossary/Terminology Maintainer

What: Maintains consistent terminology across docs, code comments, and README

Why:

• Security tools need precise terminology (ACL, NAT, DNAT, firewall, proxy, domain whitelist)
• Current docs use variations: "domain whitelisting", "allowed domains", "approved domains"
• Pelis Factory's Glossary Maintainer caught "three different terms for the same concept"

How: Create glossary and monitor for drift

---
description: Maintains terminology consistency across documentation
on:
  schedule: weekly
  workflow_dispatch:
  skip-if-match:
    query: 'is:pr is:open in:title "[Glossary]"'
    max: 1
permissions:
  contents: read
tools:
  github:
    toolsets: [default]
  edit:
safe-outputs:
  create-pull-request:
    title-prefix: "[Glossary] "
    labels: [documentation]
timeout-minutes: 10
---

# Glossary Maintainer

1. Read docs/GLOSSARY.md (create if missing) with canonical terms:
   - Domain whitelisting (not "allowlist", "approved domains")
   - Squid proxy (not "proxy server", "HTTP proxy")
   - Container (not "Docker container" in user-facing docs)
   - Agent container vs Squid container (be specific)
   
2. Search codebase for terminology variations in:
   - All *.md files
   - Code comments in src/
   - CLI help text in src/cli.ts
   
3. Create PR standardizing terminology to match glossary

Effort: Low (1-2 hours + initial glossary creation)
Impact: Medium - improves professionalism and clarity

---

P1 - Plan for Near-Term (High Impact, Medium Effort)

4. Metrics Collector for Agent Ecosystem

What: Meta-agent that tracks all workflow runs, costs, success rates, and generates weekly reports

Why:

• Running 15 agentic workflows with no visibility into aggregate performance
• Pelis Factory: "You can't optimize what you don't measure"
• Portfolio Analyst found workflows "costing money unnecessarily"
• Meta-agents are "incredibly valuable"

How: Adapt Pelis Factory's Metrics Collector

---
description: Tracks workflow performance across the agent ecosystem
on:
  schedule: weekly
  workflow_dispatch:
permissions:
  actions: read
  contents: read
tools:
  github:
    toolsets: [actions]
  cache-memory: true
safe-outputs:
  create-discussion:
    category: Analytics
timeout-minutes: 15
---

# Agent Ecosystem Metrics Collector

Analyze all workflow runs from the past 7 days:

1. **Success Rates**: Which workflows fail most often?
2. **Execution Times**: Which are approaching timeout limits?
3. **PR/Issue Creation**: How many outputs per workflow?
4. **Cost Estimation**: Based on GitHub Actions minutes used
5. **Trends**: Compare with cache-memory/metrics-history.json

Create discussion with:
- Summary dashboard
- Top 3 workflows by failures
- Top 3 by execution time
- Recommendations for optimization

Store detailed metrics in cache-memory for trend analysis.

Effort: Medium (4-6 hours to implement)
Impact: High - enables data-driven optimization

---

5. Duplicate Code Detector with Semantic Analysis

What: Weekly scan for duplicated logic across TypeScript files using semantic code analysis

Why:

• TypeScript codebase with similar patterns (Docker, iptables, Squid)
• Pelis Factory uses Serena for semantic analysis beyond text matching
• Catches "same logic with different variable names"

How: Adapt Duplicate Code Detector

---
description: Finds duplicate code patterns using semantic analysis
on:
  schedule: weekly
  workflow_dispatch:
  skip-if-match:
    query: 'is:issue is:open in:title "[duplicate-code]"'
    max: 3
permissions:
  contents: read
tools:
  github:
    toolsets: [default]
  bash:
    - "npm ci"
    - "npm run build"
safe-outputs:
  create-issue:
    title-prefix: "[duplicate-code] "
    labels: [refactoring]
timeout-minutes: 20
---

# Duplicate Code Detector

Analyze TypeScript files in src/ for duplicate patterns:

1. Focus on files changed in last 30 days
2. Look for:
   - Similar function signatures
   - Repeated error handling patterns
   - Duplicated validation logic
   - Similar Docker/iptables command construction
   
3. Create issues for significant duplication:
   - 10+ lines repeated
   - Appears in 3+ locations
   
4. Include specific file references and refactoring suggestions
5. Limit to 3 issues per run to avoid overwhelm

Effort: Medium (3-4 hours)
Impact: Medium - improves maintainability

---

6. Documentation Site Multi-Device Tester

What: Weekly Playwright tests of docs-site across mobile, tablet, desktop

Why:

• Astro docs-site likely responsive but untested
• Pelis Factory's Multi-device Tester caught "visual regressions and layout issues that only appear on specific screen sizes"
• Critical for professional documentation

How: Use Playwright in workflow

---
description: Tests documentation site across devices
on:
  schedule: weekly
  workflow_dispatch:
permissions:
  contents: read
tools:
  bash:
    - "npm ci"
    - "npx playwright:*"
safe-outputs:
  create-issue:
    title-prefix: "[Docs UI] "
    labels: [documentation, ui]
timeout-minutes: 15
---

# Documentation Site Multi-Device Tester

1. Install dependencies in docs-site/
2. Build the docs site
3. Start local server
4. Run Playwright tests across:
   - Mobile (375px)
   - Tablet (768px)
   - Desktop (1920px)
   
5. Test:
   - Navigation menu works
   - Code examples are readable
   - Search functionality
   - All pages load without errors
   
6. Create issue if any device fails with screenshots

Effort: Medium (4-6 hours with Playwright setup)
Impact: Medium - professional documentation quality

---

P2 - Consider for Roadmap (Medium Impact)

7. Security Compliance Campaign Tracker

What: Track vulnerability remediation campaigns with deadlines and progress reporting

Why:

• Pelis Factory pattern for "audit in 3 weeks" scenarios
• Useful for CVE response tracking
• Example: Issue [Security] js-yaml security update ready for merge #413 (js-yaml security update) could be tracked in campaign

How: Campaign-based issue tracking with deadlines

Effort: High (6-8 hours)
Impact: Medium - useful during security audits

---

8. Performance Monitoring for Firewall Operations

What: Weekly analysis of firewall overhead, container startup times, proxy latency

Why:

• Performance matters for CI/CD adoption
• No current monitoring of firewall impact
• Could identify optimization opportunities

How: Benchmark workflows with metrics extraction

Effort: High (8+ hours with benchmarking setup)
Impact: Medium - optimize performance

---

9. Network Traffic Pattern Analyzer

What: Weekly analysis of Squid logs to identify common domain patterns and suggest additions to documentation

Why:

• Squid logs contain rich data about actual usage
• Could surface commonly blocked domains that should be documented
• Security insights from traffic patterns

How: Parse Squid logs from test runs

Effort: High (6-8 hours)
Impact: Low-Medium - insights rather than automation

---

P3 - Future Ideas

10. Continuous Refactoring Workflow

What: Weekly structural improvements beyond simplification (extract modules, improve abstractions)

Why: Complement code simplifier with deeper refactoring

Effort: High
Impact: Medium

---

11. Multi-Phase Test Coverage Campaign

What: Long-running (multi-week) campaign to systematically achieve 90%+ coverage

Why: Pelis Factory pattern for complex coordinated work

Effort: High
Impact: Medium (test-coverage-improver already exists)

---

12. Organization-Wide Workflow Syncer

What: If multiple repos use awf, sync common workflows

Why: Pelis Factory has org-wide patterns

Effort: High
Impact: Low (only relevant if ecosystem grows)

---

📈 Maturity Assessment

Current Level: 4/5 (Advanced)

Rating Scale:

• Level 1 - No automation (manual everything)
• Level 2 - Basic CI/CD only
• Level 3 - Some agentic workflows (1-3)
• Level 4 - Comprehensive agentic workflows (10-20) ⬅️ You are here
• Level 5 - Agent factory (20+) with meta-agents monitoring ecosystem

What it Does Well ✅

1. Security Automation - 5/5 workflows including Security Guard, daily reviews, dependency monitoring
2. CI Failure Investigation - CI Doctor is Docker/network-aware, very relevant
3. Issue Management - Issue Monster, duplicate detector, triage
4. Documentation Maintenance - Daily doc-maintainer syncs with code changes
5. Test Coverage - Weekly improver focused on security-critical paths
6. Configuration Patterns - Good use of skip-if-match, title-prefixes, network restrictions

What it Could Improve 🔧

1. Code Quality Automation - Missing simplification, duplicate detection, continuous refactoring
2. Meta-Agent Monitoring - No metrics collector, portfolio analyst, or audit workflows
3. Documentation Validation - No docs-site testing, glossary maintenance, or noob testing
4. Workflow Activation - ~5 workflows lack triggers and may be dormant
5. Shared Patterns - Limited use of imports/ for common logic
6. Multi-Phase Workflows - No long-running coordinated campaigns

Target Level: 5/5 (Agent Factory)

To achieve Level 5:

• ✅ Already has 15 workflows (good foundation)
• ➕ Add 5-10 more workflows (code quality, metrics, validation)
• ➕ Implement meta-agents (metrics collector, portfolio analyst)
• ➕ Create shared/ directory with common patterns
• ➕ Weekly metrics discussion with ecosystem health dashboard

Gap Analysis

Category	Current	Target	Gap
Total Workflows	15	20-25	+5-10
Active (with triggers)	~10	20-25	+10-15
Meta-Agents	1 (advisor)	3-4	+2-3
Code Quality	0	2-3	+2-3
Documentation	2	4-5	+2-3
Security	5	5-6	✅ Strong
Metrics/Analytics	0	2-3	+2-3

---

🔄 Comparison with Best Practices

Strengths Compared to Pelis Factory

1. Security-Domain Focus - More comprehensive security workflows than general Pelis patterns
2. CI-Aware Diagnostics - CI Doctor understands Docker networking issues specific to this project
3. Test-Driven Security - Test coverage improver prioritizes security-critical code paths
4. Good Configuration Hygiene - Follows skip-if-match, timeout-minutes, title-prefix patterns

Unique Opportunities (Security/Firewall Domain)

1. Firewall Rule Validation Workflow - Daily validation that iptables rules match expected state
2. Network Traffic Compliance Monitor - Verify no unauthorized domains in Squid logs
3. Container Security Hardening Tracker - Monitor Docker security configurations (capabilities, seccomp)
4. Performance Regression Detector - Catch firewall overhead increases
5. Security Documentation Auditor - Verify security guidance matches implementation

Adoption Recommendations

From Pelis Factory proven patterns, prioritize:

1. ✅ Code Simplifier - Most immediately useful for TypeScript codebase
2. ✅ Metrics Collector - Essential for managing 15+ workflow ecosystem
3. ✅ Documentation Validator - Critical for security tool adoption
4. ⚠️ Portfolio Analyst - Only needed if cost becomes concern
5. ⚠️ Multi-Phase Workflows - Good for complex campaigns, not urgent

---

📝 Notes for Future Runs

Patterns Observed (stored in cache-memory):

• Strong security workflow foundation
• Good workflow hygiene (prefixes, skip-if-match)
• Documentation site exists but untested
• No meta-agent monitoring of ecosystem
• TypeScript codebase suitable for code quality workflows

Changes to Track:

• Workflow activation status (check dormant workflows)
• New workflows added since this assessment
• Metrics collection implementation
• Code quality workflow adoption

Next Assessment Should Check:

1. How many P0 recommendations were implemented?
2. Are dormant workflows now active?
3. Has metrics collection started?
4. What's the workflow success rate trend?

---

🎯 Implementation Roadmap

Week 1-2: Quick Wins (P0)

• Implement Code Simplifier workflow
• Add Documentation Site Validator
• Create Glossary and Terminology Maintainer
• Activate dormant workflows (add triggers)

Month 1: High-Impact Features (P1)

• Implement Metrics Collector
• Add Duplicate Code Detector
• Set up Documentation Site Multi-Device Tester
• Create weekly metrics discussion automation

Quarter 1: Advanced Features (P2)

• Security Compliance Campaign Tracker
• Performance Monitoring workflows
• Network Traffic Pattern Analyzer
• Shared patterns library (imports/)

Ongoing

• Weekly review of metrics dashboard
• Monthly assessment of workflow ecosystem health
• Quarterly comparison with Pelis Factory patterns
• Continuous refinement based on usage data

---

📚 References

• Pelis Agent Factory Welcome
• Meet the Workflows - 19 part series
• Continuous Simplicity
• Security & Compliance Workflows
• Documentation Workflows
• Metrics & Analytics Workflows
• Agentics Reference Repo

---

Generated by Pelis Agent Factory Advisor • 2026-01-26

AI generated by Pelis Agent Factory Advisor

• expires on Feb 2, 2026, 9:00 PM UTC

[github-actions[bot]]

This discussion was automatically closed because it expired on 2026-02-02T21:00:33.295Z.