Discuss is now not presenting questions at all

[Morphix84]

GSD Version

1.22.1

Runtime

Claude Code

What happened?

When running /gsd:discuss-phase X, GSD will attempt to present various questions (presumably using the AskUserTool), but the questions are not rendered and will just be skipped as if they have been asked and answered. The questions can be presented by interrupting the model and telling it that you can't see the questions, whereby it will ask them in text instead of using the AskUserTool. An example:

User answered Claude's questions:
⎿  
● All four areas selected. Let's work through each.
Let's talk about Map layout & region placement.
● User answered Claude's questions:
⎿  
● User answered Claude's questions:
⎿  
● User answered Claude's questions:
⎿  

What did you expect?

When using the discuss feature, the questions should be rendered. If the previous context would recommend an answer already, that choice being made should be rendered as well.

Steps to reproduce

1. Start a new project
2. Run /gsd:discuss-phase 1

Relevant logs or error messages

[pogestudio]

It's a bug in claude 2.1.63. downgrade to 2.1.62 and it works ^^

[mbarchein]

I think it's same error/duplicate of #858

[Tibsfox]

Hi @Morphix84! This one's been identified as a Claude Code runtime issue (around v2.1.63) rather than a GSD bug — the AskUserQuestion tool prompts are getting auto-answered without rendering the UI. It affects /gsd:discuss-phase, /gsd:settings, and anywhere GSD uses interactive question prompts.

Duplicate of #803, and the workaround mentioned (downgrading CC or interrupting and asking Claude to present questions as text) is the best option until Anthropic addresses it on their end.

Suggesting close as duplicate of #803. 🙂