availableLanguages ISO country/language codes should be lowercase, but intendedAudience.countries MUST BE uppercase

[rklec]

I came from #275 and thanks to my IDE noticed a "discrepancy" in the standard.

As for the key intendedAudience.countries it forces uppercase letters/ISO language codes (in the latest standard apparently; cannot find that change in the release docs though), as https://editor.opencode.de/ still gave me lowercase letters):

This seems to be compliant as per https://yml.publiccode.tools/schema.core.html#key-intendedaudience-countries:

All countries are specified using lowercase (deprecated) or uppercase ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 two-letter country codes.

(which BTW, the example in https://guide.opencode.de/assets/code/publiccode.yml still does explicitly wrong)

However, the key localisation.availableLanguages apparently uses lowercase letters?

Example: "it", "en", "sl-IT-nedis"

https://yml.publiccode.tools/schema.core.html#key-localisation-availablelanguages

I know countries and languages are something different and the last one follow a different standard, but anyway, this was very confusing for me.

[fvsamson]

However, the key localisation.availableLanguages apparently uses lowercase letters?

Example: "it", "en", "sl-IT-nedis"

https://yml.publiccode.tools/schema.core.html#key-localisation-availablelanguages

I know countries and languages are something different and the last one follow a different standard, but anyway, this was very confusing for me.

Exactly: This is important for readability, because Country Code (uppercase) and Language Code (lowercase) can be combined for local variants of a language, e.g. en_GB, en_US, en_NZ en-GB, en-US, en-NZ etc.

[bfabio]

Languages in publiccode.yml are all BCP47, en_GB is not a pure BCP 47 tag, that would be en-GB.

But anyway, BCP 47 is not case sensitive per se, but it's recommended to preserve the casing used in the registry from IANA

[bfabio]

I came from #275 and thanks to my IDE noticed a "discrepancy" in the standard.

Your IDE uses the official, up to date JSON schema to provide you an approximate guidance on the syntax, but it can't express "in this field this format is deprecated, you should use that other format", so it just defines the non deprecated format.

As for the key intendedAudience.countries it forces uppercase letters/ISO language codes (in the latest standard apparently; cannot find that change in the release docs though)

It's the second to last item in the release notes:

v0.5.0

docs(standard): use pure ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 instead of an hybrid by @bfabio in #227

This seems to be compliant as per https://yml.publiccode.tools/schema.core.html#key-intendedaudience-countries:

All countries are specified using lowercase (deprecated) or uppercase ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 two-letter country codes.

(which BTW, the example in https://guide.opencode.de/assets/code/publiccode.yml still does explicitly wrong)

Please open the relevant opencode editor's issues to their repo.

However, the key localisation.availableLanguages apparently uses lowercase letters?

Example: "it", "en", "sl-IT-nedis"

localisation.availableLanguages are languages, not countries and they use another standard, BCP 47. Besides that, they are two different concepts.

[rklec]

Please open the relevant opencode editor's issues to their repo.

Thanks for the reminder, did so: https://gitlab.opencode.de/open-code/erste-schritte/guide/-/issues/14