fix: no Debug on Display implementations#2083
fix: no Debug on Display implementations#2083Dmenec wants to merge 4 commits intobitcoindevkit:masterfrom
Debug on Display implementations#2083Conversation
492114b to
b73016e
Compare
|
Concept ACK — this approach looks good, thanks for the changes. I ran the tests locally and they all passed. While trying to recreate the initial issue’s scenario (#1933), I found that I have a few small suggestions below. Most of these are nits, but since this PR is already addressing the area, I thought it’d be reasonable to mention them here:
|
evanlinjin
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Quality work.
Just a couple requested changes:
- Commit messages should contain a scope (as mentioned in the conventional commits spec). The scope should be the name of the package affected:
core,chain,example, etc. - Commits that break the API should be marked with
!.
And a nit:
- Error messages should be somewhat consistent. I personally don't think we should suggest actions in the message, just state what the error is.
|
@Dmenec are you able to make progress on this? |
b73016e to
532e2ec
Compare
|
@evanlinjin Pushed the updates. Let me know if everything checks out :) |
evanlinjin
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
utACK 532e2ec
I'm happy with how this is looking. Unable to test until I have access to a computer again.
789d8a3 to
d65eed0
Compare
|
Having some trouble with the no_std CI check for the esplora crate... Does it actually support no_std, or should be treated as std‑only? |
@Dmenec It's now fixed on master, a rebase should fix it. |
f0698e1 to
d65eed0
Compare
d65eed0 to
ae17df2
Compare
91abd25 to
75d1bd0
Compare
evanlinjin
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Sorry for the bike-shedding. We're very close.
oleonardolima
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Overall it looks good, it just need to address Evan's comments.
…iptorError Replace Debug-based formatting with user-friendly Display messages.
2763989 to
744a3de
Compare
…eError Limited to 3 max shown items and added a suffix when there are additional entries.
…rror. Format magic bytes as 0x-prefixed hex.
744a3de to
823e4e9
Compare
Description
Fixes #1933, remove the usage of
DebugonDisplayimplemetations mentioned in #1881 (comment)Changelog notice
Debugusage withDisplaymessages forInsertDescriptorError,CalculateFeeErrorandStoreError.InvalidMagicBytesnow displays expected and actual bytes in hexadecimal instead of usingDebug.short_descriptorfunction to shorten descriptors for concise error output.SyncRequestDisplayfor Esplora and Electrum examples.Checklists
All Submissions:
just check,just fmtandjust testbefore committing