[template] Simplify the success clause in the charter template#716
[template] Simplify the success clause in the charter template#716
Conversation
Removed a redundant sentence regarding open test suites in the charter template.
tantek
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I disagree with this change. We asked for this line to be put back as a temporary fix the problem of oversimplification in the success criteria previously which dropped the "complete" test suite requirement for every feature, and also errantly dropped the need for sending/receiving or publishing/consuming implementations to interoperate with each other.
|
The current paragraph is, stylistically, very ugly in my view. We have two sentences in a row which both begin with
and, in my reading, the only real difference between the two sentences is that the second refers to a test suite, whereas the first talks about individual tests. I realize this is not a literary text, but our documents should have a minimal stylistic quality in my view. If the simple deletion is not acceptable, maybe a more thorough rewording of the paragraph is necessary, but I am not sure what exactly the full message should be. |
Removed a redundant sentence regarding open test suites in the charter template.